T38 A Very Incomplete Review of Literature
- all authors agree on how to transform the volume
sdd - all authors (except Popovic 2008 ...) agree on how to transform pressure
sdsd - we agree with Einstein, Planck and Landsberg on how to transform quantities of heat, while Eddington, Blanusa and Ott write the root factor in the denominator
saddsa - for none of these renowned authors the temperature is invariant. It cannot be, since they all assume that k jand hence the entropy S jare invariant
sdff - for Einstein and Planck, the temperature decreases by the root factor with increasing relativistic velocities while with Eddington, Ott and some others it correspondingly increases
sdfsd - in 1969 van Kampen stated that the measurement of a temperature of a fast-moving object is not possible, and, therefore, temperatures cannot be sensibly transformed within the STR
saad - Landsberg claimed in 1970, that temperature and entropy are invariant. Avramov said in 2003 that this was the first attempt to set temperature as an invariant value
sddf - in 1996 Landsberg and Matsas claim that in the STR no consistent transformation can be specified for the temperature
sds - Avramov in 2003 makes a good case for the claim that the temperature is invariant, and he correctly concludes that jk jand the entropy S jmust transform
sddas - in 2006 Khaleghy and Qassemi again argued that temperatures would increase with increasing relativistic velocity
sdd - in 2007 Cubero and Hänggi do a computer simulation of a one-dimensional (!) gas and come to the conclusion that temperature can be considered to be an invariant value
asd - Popovic touted in 2008 that P' j=j P · √ ( along with T' j= T nand S' j= S )
asas - in 2008 Requard attacks with the entire arsenal of tensor calculus. He assumes without reflection that
S' j= S jand ends with the results of Eddington and Ott
sads - Gérard P. Michon, on his website (2000 - 2013) also assumes S' j= S jand, logically correct, comes to the same results as Einstein and Planck ('von Mosengeil's formula').
asd - finally in 2013 a unknown physics teacher writes this review article, attempting thereby to help the concept of Avramov and Cubero/Hänggi to a breakthrough ...
sdd - at least a dozen other publications have thrown no new light on the situation
m1m | Planck, Max, Zur Dynamik bewegter Systeme, 1907, http://wikilivres.ca/wiki/Zur_Dynamik_bewegter_Systeme |
m2 | von Mosengeil, Kurd, Theorie der stationären Strahlung, 1907, Annalen der Physik |
m3 | Pauli, Wolfgang, Enzyklopädie-Artikel von 1920 Link |
m4 | Eddington, Arthur Stanley, The Mathematical Theory of Relativity, Cambridge Univ. Press, 1923 |
m5 | Blanusa, D. und Kolokvij, Proceedings: Prvi kongres mat. i. fiz. FNRJ, 1947 |
m6 | Ott, H., Zeitschrift für Physik 175, 1963 |
m7 | Landsberg, Peter T., A critical Review of Thermodynamics, Mono Books Baltimore p.253 ff, 1970 |
m8 | Landsberg, Peter T., Nature 213 p.571 (1966) and Nature 214 p.903 (1967) |
m9 | Landsberg, P. und Matsas, G. , Phys. Lett. A vol. 223 p.401 , 1996 |
j10 | Avramov, I., Relativity and Temperature, Russian Journal of Physical Chemistry vol.77 p.179, 2003 Link |
j11 | Khaleghy, M. und Quassemi, F. , Relativistic Temperature Transformation Revisited, Seept 2006 Link |
j12 | Cubero, D. Hänggi, P. u.a. , Thermal Equilibrium ... , Phys.Rev.Letters 99 170601 , 2007 Link |
j13 | Popovic, Marko, "... analysis of relativistic Temperature transformation ..." , 2008 Link |
j14 | Requard, M. , "Thermodynamics meets SRT", arXiv:0801.2639v1 , 2008 Link |
j15 | Michon, Gérard P., on "www.numericana.com" (2000 - 2013) , Link |